Permanent Observer The Blog of the Center for UN and Global Governance Studies Home RSS Feed Twitter Talking development: Understanding contributions to the post-2015 agenda – March 15, 2014Posted in: blogposts, Martin Edwards As we approach 2015, the development agenda is becoming increasingly complex. The model for building the post-2015 sustainable development goals (hereafter SDGs) differs from that used to create the Millennium Development Goals. This time, the conventional intergovernmental negotiations have been preceded by a high level of civil society engagement. The UN’s sponsored World We Want project uses information from country consultations in 88 countries, the findings of 12 thematic discussions, as well as findings from internet surveys to map how civil society prioritizes these new goals. Understanding the dialogue surrounding the sustainable development goals can tell us something meaningful about the involvement of global civil society. With this new access, is civil society driving the conversation? With all of this information comes the challenge of making sense of it. Some organizations have responded to the challenge of greater civil society engagement by trying to summarize the conversation. The Overseas Development Institute’s Future Goals Tracker tracks who is making proposals for the SDGs. A similar effort is led by the Stakeholder Forum’s E-Inventory. The North-South Institute uses data from the Future Goals Tracker to assess the relative count of different proposed themes for the post-2015 development agenda, and NSI has released a more extensive report evaluating some of these proposals. The World We Want project also has a number of different data visualization tools to summarize the discussions on the website and through social media. For someone interested in the politics of these discussions, these are a rich resource to understand who is leading the conversation regarding the SDGs. As an initial appraisal, I downloaded the data from ODI’s Future Goals Tracker and have summarized it below. The website contains 367 proposed goals disseminated between 2009 and 2014. The goals are categorized by who is proposing, the country of the proposer, and what the proposal actually was. Some of the proposers are classified as country specific, such as an NGO operating in a specific country or a government, and others are classified as global, representing an NGO with global reach or an international organization. Some key findings follow below. Proposers had limited global reach. There were 202 proposals from 28 countries in the dataset. Over half of the proposals (N=114) came from proposers based in the US and UK, and 79% (N=161) of the proposals came from countries classified by the World Bank as ‘high income.’ In the top ten proposing countries, there are only three classified as middle income: Philippines (11 proposals), Colombia (10 proposals) and China (3 proposals). Strong civil society presence. At the country level, 86% (N=173) were proposed by civil society organizations based in specific countries. At the global level, 31% (N=51) were proposed by civil society organizations. In sum, 61% (N = 224) of the proposals in the Future Goals Tracker were made by civil society organizations at either the country or global levels. Significant UN engagement. The SDGs are engaging numerous UN agencies. At the global level, the majority of global proposals are made by UN agencies, other international organizations that are part of the UN system, or multistakeholder partnerships in which the UN plays a considerable role. 62% of these global proposals (N=102) came from UN and UN related agencies. This is in addition to the UN’s role in channeling civil society debate through the aforementioned World We Want Project. The 12 thematic summaries from the World We Want project are not included in the above total. Of course, it is too early to make statements about the relative impact of civil society on the SDGs. This is a process that has yet to fully play out. It is clear from the above findings, however, that while civil society is an active partner, we have a long way to go to make the conversation about the SDGs a truly global one. Martin S. Edwards Tags: civil society, post-2015, SDGs Trackbacks / Pings Talking development: Understanding contributions to the post-2015 agenda | Post2015.org - what comes after the MDGs? Leave a Reply Cancel reply Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked * Name * Email * Website Comment You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> Recent Tweets Coming up this week: http://t.co/ibLxFNCWOp Reply Retweet Favorite 4:02pm - 22 Sep '14 - 7 hours ago New on the blog today: @rimuresa reviews the NATO Summit. http://t.co/tE0zGnh5lA #NATOSummitUK Reply Retweet Favorite 12:50pm - 22 Sep '14 - 11 hours ago @baysontheroad Nice segment on @ajam tonight on your upcoming very busy week! Reply Retweet Favorite 12:43am - 22 Sep '14 - 23 hours ago @shuDiplomacy tweeps: Today's #mustread is the awesome Friday newsletter from @fpinterrupted! #inspiring Reply Retweet Favorite 1:02pm - 19 Sep '14 - 3 days ago Congratulation for friend @Isobel_Coleman for nomination by POTUS to be US rep to UN for UN management & reform, with rank of Ambassador Reply Retweet Favorite 12:15pm - 19 Sep '14 - 3 days ago Follow @SHU_UN_Studies UN News Centre – Top Stories Cairo+20: General Assembly reaffirms UN population and development goals September 22, 2014 FEATURE: Juggling a cacophony of tongues, UN interpreters avert linguistic disaster September 22, 2014 UN agency steps up aid operations as 130,000 Syrian refugees cross into Turkey September 22, 2014 Advance team of UN mission for Ebola response arrives in West Africa September 22, 2014 Success of Indigenous Peoples World Conference 'integral to humanity's progress' September 22, 2014 Blogroll UN Dispatch CFR Global Governance Monitor GenUN Youth Observer Blog UN Foundation Global Connections Blog Security Council Report - What's in Blue PassBlue One Earth Future Foundation Peace Talks Blog Council on Foreign Relations: The Internationalist Rising BRICSAM G20 Studies Centre Future UN Development System Project Blog Global Observatory Exploring Digital Diplomacy Opinio Juris Asian Security Blog Policy Innovations Duck of Minerva Daniel Drezner Monkey Cage Running Numbers 400 South Orange Avenue South Orange, NJ 07079 About Arras WordPress Theme Copyright Seton Hall University School of Diplomacy and International Relations. All Rights Reserved.